US states sue generic firms over ‘inflated’ prices
Companies accused of “multi-billion dollar fraud" and conspiracy
A wide-ranging lawsuit has been filed in the US by 44 states, claiming price fixing for dozens of widely-used generic medicines.
All told, 20 pharma companies are cited in the lawsuit, including Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Novartis’ Sandoz unit, Mylan, and Pfizer, amongst others, which are accused of perpetrating a “multi-billion dollar fraud on the American people.”
The legal action was filed on Friday by Connecticut Attorney General William Tong, and follows a five-year investigation into the alleged conspiracy to fix prices and allocate markets for more than 100 different generics, including drugs for heart disease, diabetes and cancer.

Teva, Sandoz, Mylan and Pfizer have all been cited in the lawsuit
During the probe, the states issued more than 300 subpoenas to various telephone carriers, and have obtained phone call and text message records for companies and individuals throughout the generic drug industry that they say prove a conspiracy.
It claims that the usual dynamics of the generics market – with the first generic to launch reducing the price from the brand slightly and a big fall-off after the second and subsequent generics enter the market – has changed.
“Prices for hundreds of generic drugs have risen – while some have skyrocketed, without explanation,” it says.
15 industry executives are also cited by name in the lawsuit, most of whom held senior sales, marketing or commercial positions at the named pharmaceutical companies.
The complaint alleges that during a 19-month period from July 2013 to January 2015, “Teva significantly raised prices on approximately 112 different generic drugs. Of those 112 different drugs, Teva colluded with…competitors on at least 86 of them (the others were largely in markets where Teva was exclusive).”
It adds: “The size of the price increases varied, but a number of them were well over 1,000%.”
This is the second suit to be filed in connection with the investigation. The first – which is still pending – was submitted in 2016 and covers 18 corporate defendants, two individual defendants, and 15 generic drugs.
According to Tong, an interconnected web of industry executives was created in which competitors met at “industry dinners, ‘girls nights out’, lunches, cocktail parties, golf outings and communicated via frequent telephone calls, emails and text messages that sowed the seeds for their illegal agreements.”
The result was unlawfully discouraged competition, elevated prices and an ingrained culture of collusion.
In a statement, Teva said “the allegations in this new complaint, and in the litigation more generally, are just that – allegations. Teva continues to review the issue internally and has not engaged in any conduct that would lead to civil or criminal liability.”
美国已有 44 个州提起了范围广泛的诉讼,声称对数十种广泛使用的仿制药实施了价格操纵。总共,20 家制药公司在诉讼中被引用,包括梯瓦制药美国,诺华的山德士单位,迈兰,辉瑞等,这些被指控犯下了“数十亿美元的欺诈美国人民。“康涅狄格州总检察长 William Tong 在周五提起诉讼,并对涉嫌串谋定价和为 100 多种不同仿制药(包括心脏病、糖尿病和癌症药物)分配市场进行了为期五年的调查。Teva、Sandoz、Mylan 和 Pfizer 都曾在调查期间的诉讼中被引用,各州向各种电话运营商发出了 300 多份传票,并获得了整个仿制药行业的公司和个人的电话和短信记录,他们说这证明是阴谋。它声称,仿制药市场的通常动态——第一个推出的仿制药稍微降低了品牌的价格,第二个和后续仿制药进入市场后大幅下降——已经改变。报告称:“数百种非专利药的价格已经上涨——而一些非专利药的价格却飞涨,原因不明。”15 名行业高管在诉讼中也被点名,其中大多数人在指名的制药公司担任高级销售、营销或商业职位。该投诉声称,在 2013 年 7 月至 2015 年 1 月的 19 个月期间,“梯瓦显著提高了大约 112 种不同仿制药的价格。在这 112 种不同的药物中,Teva 至少在其中 86 种药物上与……竞争对手勾结(其他药物主要在 Teva 独家的市场)。它补充说:“涨价的规模各不相同,但其中有一些涨幅远远超过了 1000%。”“这是就调查提出的第二项诉讼。第一个——目前仍悬而未决——于 2016 年提交,涵盖 18 名公司被告、2 名个人被告和 15 种仿制药。据童说,一个相互关联的行业高管网络是在“行业晚宴、“女孩之夜”、午餐会、鸡尾酒会、高尔夫郊游以及通过频繁的电话、电子邮件和短信等方式进行沟通,为他们的非法协议播下了种子。“其结果是,非法抑制了竞争,抬高了价格,形成了根深蒂固的串通文化。在一份声明中,Teva 说:“在这一新的控诉中,以及在更广泛的诉讼中,指控仅仅是指控。Teva 继续在内部审查该问题,没有从事任何可能导致民事或刑事责任的行为。”
扫码实时看更多精彩文章

